Welcome to the Lou Zar Speakeasy, where the drinks and clues are endlessly flowing.

Things are not as they first seem at this ‘legitimate Italian restaurant’. Behind the curtain lies an illegal speakeasy run by a mafia family and filled to the brim with seedy characters. With members of the mob in attendance at this mystery dinner, someone is bound to lose an eye… or even their life!

Don your best flapper dress, hop on the trolley, and head down to Carmine’s in NYC for an exciting murder mystery dinner theater show that you’ll never forget.

Meet a few of the (Un)usual Suspects

When you join us for a night of murder mystery dinner theater you’ll be accompanied by a variety of questionable characters. From mob boss Lou Zar to the songstress Lucy Morals, the night’s cast of characters is one you may want to familiarize yourself with.

Curious about what to expect at our murder mystery dinner theater?

Dive into an evening where suspense and immersive drama unfold with every course served. From the first act to the gripping conclusion, anticipate a night filled with intrigue and a challenge to uncover the murderer among you. Discover the full experience here.

Never been to a murder mystery dinner show and curious what will unfold?

Here’s a rundown of what to anticipate after you’ve settled in with your meal.

Step 1: Assigning Roles.

As you arrive an find your seats, our actors will begin mingling with guests. They’ll select 8-12 attendees to act as ‘suspects’ (maybe even one of the suspects above!), identifiable by unique accessories and nametags. Keep an eye on them; one is the ‘murderer’! If you’re not a ‘suspect’, you’ll take on the role of a ‘detective’, tasked with scrutinizing the scenes and interrogating suspects during investigation periods.

Step 2: The Performance Kicks Off.

The excitement escalates as the ‘murder’ occurs—rest assured, it’s all for show (even if it all feels real!) The show spans three acts, providing multiple opportunities to observe interactions and gather clues.

Step 3: Crack the Case!

It’s time to decide ‘whodunit’. Collaborate with your tablemates to piece together who had the motive, opportunity, and means to commit the crime. Keep in mind, there is only one correct answer for each show—your guess needs to meet all three of these criteria in order to be our killer!

Not sure what to wear to a 1920’s murder mystery dinner?

Though dressing up is not required, it is encouraged! If you are unsure what to wear to our 1920’s speakeasy, click here to take the quiz/follow their guide.

What food is being served during the performance?

A three-course Italian meal is served, featuring Carmine’s favorite dishes. Menus are available upon request, and each meal is served family style.