Titusville, PA – Murder Mystery Dinner

Solve a Crime, Enjoy a Feast: Murder Mystery Dinners Await!

Experience an unforgettable evening of delicious food, thrilling intrigue, and hilarious comedy with our Murder Mystery Dinners aboard the Oil Creek & Titusville Railroad! Test your detective skills as you try to unravel a perplexing crime while enjoying a delectable meal and then a scenic train ride.

Your evening begins at 4:45 pm inside Perry Street Station with a delightful dinner. (Due to unforeseen circumstances, caterer TBD). At 6:15 pm, we’ll depart on a 3-hour journey aboard our vintage train, where the talented actors of In All Seriousness will bring the mystery to life with a side of laugh-out-loud comedy.

As the plot thickens, you’ll gather clues, interrogate suspects, and try to deduce “whodunit.” The grand finale and dessert await back at Perry Street Station, where the mystery will be solved and prizes awarded to the cleverest sleuths.

We offer a variety of themed shows throughout the season, including “Medvale High School Mayhem” and “Mama Mia Mayhem.” Each show offers a unique and engaging experience, so you can come back again and again! (Scroll down for show dates and descriptions).

Buffet Menu:

• Rolls
• Tossed Salad
• Broccoli Salad
• Fruit Salad
• Peas & Carrots
• Roasted Red Skinned Potatoes
• Baked Chicken
• Pot Roast
• Various desserts (cakes, pies, cheesecake)

• Important Information:

  • Advanced reservations are required by calling 814-676-1733.
  • Due to some suggestive language, these events are not recommended for guests under 16.
  • The evening concludes at approximately 9:30 pm.

  More Information:

  NOTE:  Be sure to dress for the weather, Coach cars do not have air conditioning and heating is limited. Your Confirmation letter will be mailed to you after you place your order. Tickets available for pickup on event night, and will have your table and car assignments. Doors open 3:30 pm, please arrive by 4:30 pm. Dinner begins 4:45 pm. Evening concludes around 9:30 pm.

  Planning to join your friends for one of our Murder Mystery Dinners? If you are meeting someone who has a separate reservation, just let us know ahead of time, as it is assigned seating for our dinners. We’ll make every effort to see you are seated together. If tickets are done in one purchase, you will be seated together.

  No videos as the Murder Mystery shows are copyrighted by In All Seriousness.
  As this is a Special Event, pets are not permitted.  

  Accessibility Information: Our train and station have ramp access. Wheelchair space is not available for this event.

  Oil Creek & Titusville Railroad reserves the right to cancel any train ride due to circumstances beyond our control.

  Please be aware: we do not have e-tickets. Anyone trying to sell you e-tickets is trying to scam you. You can only be assured to receive verified tickets for any of our events by contacting us directly by phone at 814-676-1733, or by faxing/emailing/mailing reservation form found on our website to us.

  Why Choose a Murder Mystery Dinner Excursion?

  • Dinner & Mystery Combined: Start your evening with a delicious dinner at our historic station, then board the train for a 3-hour interactive murder mystery adventure.

  • Interactive & Entertaining: Become part of the story as you meet colorful characters, gather clues, and help solve the crime—participate as much or as little as you like.

  • Perfect for a Night Out: Ideal for date nights, groups, and celebrations, this unique experience blends dining, entertainment, and scenic rail travel into one unforgettable evening.

  • Departure Time:

    Buffet Dinner starts at 4:45 PM inside Perry Street Station. Train departs at 6:15 PM. Please plan to arrive no later than 4:30.
    Train Ride Time: Approximately 3 Hours. Event will last until approximately 9:30 pm.

    Train Boarding:

    Perry Street Station
    409 S Perry St
    Titusville, PA

    Ticket Information & Pricing:

    $80 per person

    Cost includes dinner, the train ride, show, dessert and gratuity.
    Alcohol is not permitted. Coach seating only.

    Why not make your evening truly special by staying overnight in an actual Caboose car? Call The Caboose Motel at 814-827-5730 to check availability. With only 21 Cabooses, they book up quickly!

    Advanced Ticket Reservations:

    Advanced reservations required by Phone, Email or Fax.

    Advance reservations will not be accepted after 2 pm on the Friday prior. Tickets are non-refundable. We do not have online reservations.
    

    Reservations By Phone:

    Call 814-676-1733

    Reservations By Email, Mail or Fax:

    Click here to print our Ticket Reservation Form.